Both PEX and copper are reliable choices for repiping a home. PEX is flexible, holds up better when water freezes, and can usually be installed with fewer wall openings. Copper is rigid, handles heat well, and has a long track record. The best choice depends on your home’s layout, your water, and where the pipes run.
What Each Pipe Is
- PEX (cross-linked polyethylene) is a flexible plastic tubing, often color-coded red for hot and blue for cold. It’s connected with crimp, clamp, or expansion fittings.
- Copper is a rigid metal pipe joined with soldered or press fittings. It’s been the standard in American homes for decades.
How They Compare
Installation
PEX bends around corners and can be pulled through walls in long runs with fewer fittings. That often means fewer openings in drywall and a faster job. Copper needs fittings at every turn and more access to walls and ceilings.
Freezing
PEX can expand slightly when water freezes inside it, so it’s more forgiving than copper. That doesn’t make it freeze-proof, and fittings can still fail. Copper is more likely to split when it freezes. For homes with pipes in crawl spaces or exterior walls, or for seasonal homes in Pike and Sussex counties, this matters.
Water Quality
Acidic water, which is common in some private wells, can cause pinhole leaks in copper over time. PEX isn’t affected by acidic water the same way. If your well water is acidic, test and treat it regardless of which pipe you choose.
Durability and Exposure
Copper handles heat and sunlight well. PEX must be kept out of direct sunlight and away from very high heat sources, such as the first stretch of pipe off some water heaters, according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
Noise
PEX tends to be quieter and less prone to water hammer than rigid pipe.
When Repiping Makes Sense
- Galvanized steel pipes with low pressure or rusty water
- Polybutylene pipe from the late 1970s to the mid-1990s
- Copper with repeated pinhole leaks
- A major renovation that opens walls anyway
Can You Mix Them?
Yes. Many repipes use PEX for most runs and copper in specific spots, such as near the water heater or where pipe is exposed. Transitions between materials need the right fittings.
Get Help Choosing
Jones Services has repiped homes across the Hudson Valley since 1986. Our licensed plumbers will look at your current pipes, your water, and your home’s layout, and recommend the right material with upfront pricing. Learn more about our plumbing services.